
Currently I am reading a biography on Keith Green written by his widow Melody and David Hazard. In it Melody describes the journey she and Keith traveled to accept Jesus. One of the struggles she mentioned was accepting that Jesus was God. Both Keith and Melody came from Jewish backgrounds, while Keith also was raised in Christian Science. Both Judaism and Christian Science deny that Jesus is God. So it wasn’t surprising that Jesus’ deity was an issue for them. However, their struggle reflects a struggle that many others have with Jesus.
For those of us who have known Jesus for some time and accepted who he said he was (and is), we can forget the struggle that some have in accepting all that Jesus claimed to be. Both Muslims and Jews reject Jesus’ deity, because of their view of monotheism (one God). Jehovah’s Witnesses, following Arianism, believe Jesus to be a special created being. Others view Jesus as an exemplary human being whose example we are to aspire. Orthodox Christianity teaches that Jesus was and is God, but came to that conclusion after much debate on how to explain it.
We may also forget that Jesus’ own disciples struggled to grasp and understand who he was and what he was about. Peter, after declaring Jesus to be the Messiah, failed to grasp that Jesus also was going to suffer and die, which, by the way, was prophesied in Isaiah 53. Today, many sincere seekers of truth, struggle to grasp and accept who Jesus is, particularly that he is God. That struggle can take many forms, such as how a man can become God or how a man can be God. In Jesus’ case, according to the Scriptures, Jesus didn’t become God, he was God from birth. This too, was prophesied in Isaiah 9, where the birth of a child was prophesied, who would be known as Mighty God and Everlasting Father. In Luke 2, the angel Gabriel informed Mary that the Isaiah prophecy would be fulfilled in a son she would bear. Her son would be named Jesus, he would be called the Son of the Most High God and would receive the throne of his father David on which he would reign forever, also a fulfillment of David’s prophecy in Psalm 110:1. David had written that the LORD said to his Lord that he would sit at his right hand until He made his enemies a footstool. The gospel writer John wrote in terms that his Greek readers could grasp, revealing that in the beginning was the Word (logos) and the Word was with God and God was the Word. Then he revealed that the Word became flesh in the person of Jesus. Later to the Colossians Paul wrote that all fullness of the Deity dwelt in Jesus in bodily form.
While this is all revealed in Scripture it was still a struggle for the early church to grasp and was the cause of much debate throughout the early centuries of Christianity. How were we to understand one God to have become a man? Even though the Old Testament revealed that there is one God; one of the biblical terms for God, Elohim, is actually a plural form, mysteriously indicating that in some sense this one God has some aspect of plurality. It was as if the nature of God was hiding in plain sight throughout the Old Testament.
In the fourth century a debate arose in Alexandria, Egypt between the bishop of Alexandria, Alexander and a man named Arius. Arius did not accept that Jesus was fully God, although he accepted biblical language about Jesus as reflected in what was known as the Caesarian Creed. Alexander went much further. This debate caused lines to be drawn that reached to Nicomedia, the eastern Roman capital, prior to the building of Constantinople. That debate drew in the emperor Constantine, who called for a Church council in the nearby city of Nicea. That council modified the Caesarian Creed by clarifying that Jesus was true God and the same substance or essence of God. That creed became known as the Nicean Creed and reflects what became known as the Trinitarian view of God, one God, who exists in three persons, Father, Son and Holy Spirit. While that is easy to say, it is not easy to explain. Different analogies have been offered, but they all break down. One that is mentioned in the Keith Green biography is water, existing as liquid, steam and ice, one substance existing in three forms. However, this analogy can lead to what is called a modalistic view of God, that is God appeared in three modes, first Father, then Son and finally now Holy Spirit, because water molecules can only be either liquid, ice or steam, but not all three at the same time like God, who exists simultaneously as Father, Son and Holy Spirit. As much as we would like to fully explain God, His nature remains a mystery that we can describe, but not fully explain.
Eventually Keith and Melody accepted that mystery and went on to influence many lives, mine included as I mentioned in my previous post. The fact that we cannot fully understand God should not hinder us from following Jesus any more than we would hesitate to see a doctor for an illness that is not fully understood. We build upon what we do understand and go from there. Hesitating to follow Jesus, just because we do not fully understand him means we miss out on all the joys that he has for us.